Arms Deal Truth to be Revealed |
Publication | SABC News |
Date | 2001-11-15 |
Reporter | Sapa |
Web Link | www.sabcnews.com |
Selby Baqwa, the Public Protector, Bulelani
Ngcuka, the National Director of Public Prosecutions and Shauket Fakie, the
Auditor-General will later today brief MPs about the long-awaited forensic
report into the controversial arms deal. Frene Ginwala, the National Assembly
speaker received a copy of the 250 page report yesterday.
Fakie, who is leading the forensic investigation into the deal apparently
assured Ginwala that only he and she had the final copy of the report. "The
rest are in a sealed box. He is prepared to put his head on the block about
it," she said in reply to concerns that the report had already been leaked.
Ginwala said it was the first time that the National Assembly chamber would be
used as a venue for something other than sittings of the House and speeches by
visiting Heads of State. "The three investigating heads will report to MPs
at 1:30 pm and that will constitute the tabling."
Ginwala said it was very important that all MPs heard the findings from the
investigators themselves. There would be no questions. The three would then
brief the relevant parliamentary committees and would also hold a press
conference at 3:30 pm.
SABC opens a can of worms
However, the SABC news reported yesterday, that
according to the findings the government has been cleared of any "improper
or unlawful conduct" in the arms deal. Those cleared included the president
and Cabinet ministers.
The investigators said there were no grounds to suggest the government's
contracting process was flawed, and their findings resulted from a lengthy
criminal and forensic investigation. Chippy Shaik, the chief of arms procurement
had neither received nor applied for proper military security clearance as
required by law, according to the report.
The report also does not single Joe Modise, the former defence minister out for
any wrongdoing, but says that after his retirement he become involved in a
company that benefited from the arms deal.
On the financial aspects of the arms deal, the investigators reportedly
downplayed the financial impact of the procurement, which was initially said to
be R29 billion. The report acknowledges the cost has since escalated and that
management and statutory costs were not factored into the deal when it was first
presented to Cabinet. However, the report states that 'the decision about what
the country can and cannot afford is ultimately one of political choice'.
Political parties speaks out
Meanwhile, it has emerged that at least six MPs
from four political parties were served with subpoenas by the Scorpions on
Monday, but these were revoked a day later. The subpoenas were withdrawn after
Ginwala, raised concerns about the implications for parliamentary privilege and
the fact that MPs were served in Parliament without her permission, chief whips
from political parties were told yesterday.
Leonard McCarthy, the investigating director of the Scorpions, told Sapa none of
the MPs who were subpoenaed were suspects in the arms probe. They had merely
been called to explain to the investigating team their work on specific
parliamentary committees. McCarthy confirmed the subpoenas were withdrawn
because they were mistakenly issued. "Our officials erred in subpoenaing
them through the Secretary of Parliament." Moreover, it was also Ngcuka's
view that the subpoenas had not been necessary, as all the MPs had been prepared
to co-operate, McCarthy said. Ginwala said the Secretary to Parliament could not
give permission for MPs to be subpoenaed. However, it was ludicrous to claim she
had the power to order that these were revoked.
She had spoken to Ngcuka on Tuesday to express concern that MPs had been asked to give information about parliament's proceedings, which were privileged. However, Ngcuka explained the investigators were in fact trying to find out what kind of offers may have been made to MPs by companies bidding for the deal.
Ginwala said she had assured Ngcuka that
Parliament would co-operate and that after today's tabling of the report
"we will look at how we can do so". Ginwala said she was not
protecting MPs and had not told them they could not voluntarily appear before
the Scorpions, which apparently they were all willing to do.
Dirk Bakker, an NNP MP, said he and his colleague Hennie Smit were among those
subpoenaed to appear as witnesses. Bantu Holomisa, the UDM president yesterday
said Ginwala's role in the revoked subpoenas, amounted to interference in the
arms probe. "The curious part of it is that it involved Madam Speaker. What
the hell has it got to do with her?"
However, Douglas Gibson, the DA Chief Whip said he believed Ginwala had acted correctly.
With acknowledgement to Sapa and SABC News.