Publication: Business Day Issued: Date: 2008-06-25 Reporter: Franny Rabkin Reporter:

Pikoli 'Frustrated' at Delay in Ginwala Inquiry

 

Publication 

Business Day

Date 2008-06-25
Reporter Franny Rabkin
Web Link www.bday.co.za


Staff Writer

Suspended national director of public prosecutions Vusi Pikoli has expressed his frustration with yesterday's adjournment of the inquiry to establish his fitness to hold public office.

The inquiry, chaired by former parliamentary speaker Frene Ginwala, was adjourned until Friday for the government to prepare its case .

Pikoli's attorney, Aslam Moosajee, said his client was "frustrated" as he wanted the inquiry finalised.

Moosajee said Pikoli "was suspended way back, on September 23 last year.

"One would have expected the state to know the reasons for their complaint way back then. With these delays, one gets the impression that they're making their case as they go along *1."

Indications were that the government lawyers intended to call further witnesses, despite saying on Monday that justice director-general Menzi Simelani would be their last.

Ginwala was appointed by President Thabo Mbeki to investigate Pikoli's fitness for public office after the president suspended him when Pikoli was gunning for the arrest and prosecution of police commissioner Jackie Selebi.

Ginwala said on Monday that while she had given the parties the option of which witnesses to choose, "I have not relinquished my right to call any witness that may be relevant for me to discharge my mandate." When the hearing started, Ginwala said to the government's counsel that her statement should not be construed as "trying to direct which witnesses you should call".

Ginwala was also given the mandate to determine whether the relationship between Pikoli and Justice Minister Brigitte Mabandla had "irretrievably broken down" and whether he did not appreciate the "extent of the constitutional and legal oversight powers of the minister over the prosecuting authority" .

The breakdown of the relationship between Pikoli and Mabandla was one of the reasons given by Mbeki for Pikoli's suspension. Pikoli argued, however, that there was nothing wrong with his relationship with Mabandla, and the real reason for his suspension was that he had obtained a warrant to arrest Selebi.

Without Mabandla' s testimony, it can be assumed that Ginwala must find it difficult to discharge her mandate.

She refused to comment on whether Mabandla would be called as a witness. Government had, from the beginning of the hearing, stated it did not intend to call Mabandla, despite her being Pikoli's main accuser.

Other witnesses the government initially intended to call were expected to testify on issues key to the complaint.

Acting police commissioner Timothy Williams' version of the stand-off between the Scorpions and the police is disputed by Pikoli. National Intelligence Agency director-general Manala Manzini could testify about another aspect of the complaint, that the Scorpions had gathered intelligence outside of its legal mandate.

The inquiry will resume on Friday.

With acknowledgements to Franny Rabkin and Business Day.



*1       They are making their case as they go along.

Indeed, that's if there's a case to make at all.


Reading between the lines, part of the Government';s case is a racist one. They call it a problem of demographics.

Nonsense, Adv Pikoli had a situation where certain investigating teams were staffed by white investigators with both investigating experience and knowledge of their cases.

So he wants to send them overseas, for example to the UK to investigate the bribery and corruption case involving BAE Systems and Fana Hlongwane (which of course comes straight back to Thabo Mbeki) as well as to Germany investigate the bribery and corruption case involving ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems and Chippy Shaik (which of course comes straight back to Thabo Mbeki).

But Thabo does want to be investigated so he gets his minister Mabandla to do her damndest to prevent Pikoli from doing his job.

Stooge Mabandla uses Stooge Simelani to put pressure on Pikoli and when he tries to stand up to them he is accused of having a breakdown of relationship with the minister.

This is the truth - the seeds of which which came out of Stooge Simelani's own mouth under cross-examination this week.

Unfortunately Pikoli is doing himself and his case no favours by alleging that he was suspended solely because of his procurement of search and arrest warrants against Selebi.

Thabo is not that interested in protecting the unprotectable, Selebi.

Selebi's tenure as police commissioner was in any case about to expire (which has now happened or is imminent).

Thabo is only interested in protecting himself.

And Thabo's biggest vulnerabilities are investigations into bribery and corruption into the corvette platform, corvette combat suite, submarine, fighter trainer and jet fighter acquisitions under the Arms Deal.


If anyone can fault my logic, I am waiting.