Publication: Independent Online Issued: Date: 2009-02-13 Reporter: Graeme Hosken

Army's Top Officer Admits Mistakes

 

Publication 

Independent Online

Date

2009-02-13

Reporter Graeme Hosken

Web Link

www.iol.co.za



The South African Army has admitted that it has made some serious mistakes, especially when it comes to training.

The admission by army chief, Lieutenant-General Solly Shoke, was made during a media briefing on the state of the army in Pretoria.

Speaking at the SA Army College in Thaba Tshwane, Shoke said while they had made mistakes they were learning some "valuable" lessons from them.

The army has several plans through which to overhaul the way it is run and to shape it for the future to ensure that its 2020 vision - the plan for its future - is achieved.

The army recently increased the basic training of its new recruits, brought into the defence force through the Military Skills Development System (MSDS), to 22 weeks *1.

In the past a troop's basic training, which was declared inadequate, lasted only 14 weeks *2.

The MSDS programme is aimed at recruiting thousands of young men and women on a voluntary basis to bolster the SANDF.

Late in 2008 senior army officers admitted during the army's annual combat readiness exercise that there were serious causes for concern around basic training.

Concerns were raised about issues such as musketry and weapon handling skills by Major-General Vusi Masondo, who is responsible for the force's preparation.

He told a Press conference in November that troops could not be deployed if they did not have the necessary basic skills.

Fielding questions on Thursday Shoke said a number of troops had recently been sent to Brazil, India and Tunisia to undergo jungle and desert training.

Asked why this had not been done earlier and why the defence force did not have such facilities, Shoke said: "We never thought that our troops would be fighting in the desert and jungles.

"I admit that this is a shortcoming, but we are however learning valuable lessons from our shortcomings and are improving on them," he said.

Commenting on the longer period for basic training, Shoke said the time spent in the past was not enough to make a new recruit into a proper soldier.

"They were still 'mamma boys' with high school mentalities.

"We have decided that we need to turn these new recruits into proper soldiers and the only way to do that is to conduct proper training," he said.

He said other shortcomings that they were learning from were the errors that were made from the loss of capabilities around chemical and biological warfare and explosive and ordinance disposal.

"We were wrong to do this, but these capabilities are now slowly being resuscitated," he said.

Shoke said another area which needed desperate attention was the age of troops.

"We can no longer have a situation where we are stuck with 40-something-year-old troops.

"Our human resources management is the same as the public service.

"This is wrong and is a 'mistake'. We need to develop a different and separate system to rectify this and we need to do this soon if we are to breathe life back into the army," he said.

Commenting on other challenges facing the army, Shoke hinted at a major overhaul, especially when it came to addressing ill-discipline *3 and the replacement of "prime" mission equipment *4, which had to be done as quickly as possible.

"Discipline is one of the biggest problems the army is grappling with.

"Together with our legal services we are looking at mechanisms which will enable commanders to institute disciplinary measures.

"The army will be harsh with those ill-disciplined elements, which are in our midst *5. We will not hesitate to deal with them effectively and properly," he warned, adding that discipline was the cornerstone of the army's success.

Responding to questions on desperately-needed equipment, Shoke said: "The army is doing away with the 'nice-to-haves *6' and focusing on the necessities.

"We are mindful of the challenges South Africa faces, and while we would love to have all our prime equipment, we accept that there are other prime social issues which the country has to address," he said.

Related Articles

With acknowledgements to Graeme Hosken and Independent Online.



*1*2     In the 1970s and 1980s, the two decade period of the Border War, when South Africa had one of the top armies in the world, basic training was only 10 weeks.

This was sufficient as a platform for either Junior Leaders course of nine months or task training of around 16 weeks enabling a combat troop to then actually fight, even perform paratroop duties.

When the USA and the RSA decided in around late July 1975 that they better do something about the handover of Angola to the MPLA scheduled for 11 November, Col Jan Breytenbach and a few others trained black Angolan troops for mobile infantry combat in about six weeks. Okay, the initial batch of these were partly trained guerrillas, but many came fresh.

And in the next four months or so saw the SA Army's Battle Group Alpha and Battle Group Bravo fight their way nearly 2 000 km to the north obliterating everything in their way until the summer rains came down, rivers flooded which precluded advancing those last couple of hundreds kilo metres to their (hopefully) final objective.

Fine fighting troops with just a few weeks of drill and musketry training.


*3*5    This is the fundamental problem.

Not even the mammas' boys.


*5      Read Arms Deal Mark V (after SDPs, GBADS, A400M, Infantry Fighting Vehicles).

I wonder whether we'll be buying South African this time?


*6      Well this is a refreshing change for the SANDF.

The SA Navy's submarines and MEKO 200AS frigates were certainly nice to haves.

The SA Air Force's Gripens are certainly nice to have, as it a three tier training system which makes the Hawks also nice to have.

Buying ten years in advance a dozen A400M Airbus Airlifters from a company who doesn't even quite know how to go about its programme, is also a nice to have, especially when one has a clutch of about the same quantity of recently refurbished Hercules C-130 air transporters.